Thursday, March 02, 2006

oh the drama of it all!...

And so they came. They sang. They bombed. They blossomed. They dressed strangely. They annoyed us. They awed us.

Now we get to execute four of them.

Ain't this fun??

It's result night, the one-hour spectacular where we'll get a return visit from Carrie Underwood, undoubtedly another dynamic group number and, interspersed with all of that, the firing of two of the guys and two of the gals.

I love this show. [And, as a reminder, or a warning to the west coast, I'll be simulblogging throughout, hitting the publish button after each dismissal. Hey, if Carrie can shamelessly promote her platinum album, I can certainly do the same thing with my blog.]

So, who's safe, who's probably safe and whose heads are on the chopping block? I think the division is pretty clear, but this is, after all, American Idol, the folks who invented shock TV.

On the women's side, it would stun any Idol fan to see the end of Mandisa. She's turned in two decent performances in a group that has essentially gone from bland to blank. Katharine is pretty safe too, entering the semi-finals with a potload of hype and getting universally praised last week, despite a poor song choice and even poorer clothing selection this time. Paris continues to be the darling of the tweens, despite her bout with rapid aging syndrome, so she's not going anywhere anytime soon.

Kellie had one of the best performances Tuesday night, but continues to polarize voters. There are two Kellie camps: team one which detests her insincere Carrie imitation and team two which finds her endearingly sweet. [Shucks. I got into a debate with my best friends over her sincerity/insincerity.] But off-stage impressions notwithstanding, her song selection and her performance should keep her butt firmly planted on that couch tonight at least.

Lisa is another enigma. She's very much a Diana DeGarmo in that she's been groomed for this competition and technically hits her mark, but her lack of real connection is distancing her in the always-important tween/teen market. But this week, as Simon remarked, she will sail though because there were many other boot-worthy performances standing before her in line.

And that leaves the rest of the field, all of whom are ripe for an early exit.

Melissa delivered what I still consider the most entertaining performance from Tuesday night, but still, her lack of exposure and relative unknown status will plague her. But I don't think it will this week. Ayla does not have the lack-of-airtime problem, and her tomboy athlete to girly girl story was cute and will help her identify with girls everywhere (even those of us who used to be 18). Add that to the fact that she pretty much nailed a Celine song, and her stock is rising. She's still somewhat at risk, but not tonight.

Kinnik, Heather and Brenna are the most in trouble. Each of them disappointed Tuesday night and pretty much ordered their own tickets home.

On the men's side, it's going to have to take an act of Congress to remove Chris and Elliott from this show. Add Taylor to that, even though his performance last night was far less than what we've come to expect.

So with three guys firmly in the safe zone, the other seven are going to have to grab on to a lucky charm of some sort.

Gedeon probably amazed me the most last night, with his soulful rendition of a Sam Cooke classic. His attitude could still hamper him somewhat, but the thought of him on Motown night might be that lucky charm he needs to keep people dialing his number.

Ace is pretty. We want to keep looking at him. Plus he has enough credit in the bank left from the auditions and last week to keep him afloat even though he pretty much sunk to the bottom last night.

And, even though his name is showing up in bottom two lists everywhere, I still maintain that, of the teen crooners, Will has the voice that can hold its own up next to the superior entertainers. The problem for Will (and Kevin and David, for that matter) is that, if they're relying on the teen/tween vote, that vote split three ways can do nothing but hurt at least one of them. And if people think Will is safe because his performance was the best of the three, the need to save the other two could leave him hanging out to dry.

Who remains? Sway, who has tanked two weeks in a row, but did have tremendous pre-show support that could withstand a challenge. Kevin, who's a newly-anointed sex symbol and showed the most incredible maturity in playing along with the unlikeliness of it all, but turned in an uneasy and stiff performance. David, who came in as a crooner then basically sucked at it, and Bucky, who needs to let the makeover people do their thing and, like a good middle-line employee, just does his job without demanding the spotlight.

Any one of those four might be singing their song again tonight.

So, after putting it off for as long as I could, here are my predictions.

Who I want: Brenna and Brenna. (I want Brenna kicked off twice, once for each cheek.)
Who should: Brenna and Heather.
Who will: Heather and Kinnik.

Who I want: David and Sway.
Who should: Sway and David.
Who will: David and Sway.

Your turn. Who do you want, think should and will buy the farm tonight.


tag: american idol

10 Comments:

Anonymous Meg said...

yah!! Im first to comment..well I agree with you, I think Brenna SHOULD go, but actually, I dont think she WILL go.

But..ya never know.. I also think David should go too and I think Sway is pretty good, Will might be risking it, but its his looks that got him this far..plus his voice isnt that bad..

Well have to see tonight!

love,
Meg

4:41 PM, March 02, 2006  
Blogger Happy Hiker said...

I think David should go too. The guy has a great voice, but not for idol. He should go off on his own like Harry Conneck Jr. (sp?)... Ummmmm... Sway.. I second. Although I think Ace was the worst last night, he is some nice eye candy and the people will keep him around. Who knows though, they did get rid of Becky.

Elliot, what a great voice. My boyfriend and I agree that he is a cute version of Gomer Pile. It was clear that Taylor and Chris will go very far in this competition. We'll see.

The girls... I am thinking Kinnick and Heather too. Brenna will stick around for the drama effect.

I will be watching Survivor tonight, so I will check your blog to see who won. ; )

6:59 PM, March 02, 2006  
Blogger jennifer said...

LOL Hiker. I'll be taping Survivor!

7:42 PM, March 02, 2006  
Anonymous Gina said...

Jennifer.....great job on your blog. I've been following it for 2 years now. I think one of the guys, Chris in particular, could very well be the winner this year. I know it's WAY early in the season to say this. And we all remember what happened to Tamyra Gray, so I'll not say it again until we are firmly into the semi-finals. I'm looking forward to watching Carrie on AI tonight. I picked her to win last year. Keep up the awesome blog, Jennifer!

7:43 PM, March 02, 2006  
Blogger jennifer said...

Gina, I've NEVER picked the right one this early, so I'm keeping my mouth closed. LOL And Kelly was the only one of my favorites to win, but I was a Tamyra fan until Big Band night.

:::zipping mouth:::

7:46 PM, March 02, 2006  
Blogger jennifer said...

Oh...and thanks for the kind words. I appreciate it. And I'm so glad my AOL friends stayed with me.

7:47 PM, March 02, 2006  
Blogger Annie said...

I think Brenna should be booted twice...one for her body, one for her attitude/ego. I didn't like Heather and her butchering, so I think she'll go too.

As far as the guys, I agree with you--David and Sway.

Annie =)

7:48 PM, March 02, 2006  
Blogger Two Write Hands said...

Love the comments about Brenna. I too was glad to see her go. I don't know how she made it as far as she did!

3:04 PM, March 03, 2006  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

May I ask why you left AOL?

9:37 PM, March 03, 2006  
Blogger jennifer said...

Of course. It's no secret. I left AOL for the same reason that about 250 others did. They stuck advertisements on our blogs after telling us they wouldn't.

Besides, there are many more capabilities here than there. There is great for starting out, though. Terrific people. Great community.

9:58 PM, March 03, 2006  

Post a Comment

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home


Thanks Rob for the awesome image!