and to think it only took them 4 months to figure it out...
posted by jennifer at 10:45:00 AM
Saturday, April 18, 2009
Who writes this?
My name is Jennifer, and I'm a fan. I'm no expert. I just know what I like. And what I don't.
Season 8 Finalists
Adam Lambert
Runner-up
Alexis Grace
11th Place
Allison Iraheta
TOTALLY ROBBED!
Anoop Desai
6th Place
Danny Gokey
3rd Place
Jasmine Murray
12th Place
Jorge Nunez
12th Place
Lil Rounds
7th Place
Kris Allen
AMERICAN IDOL
Matt Giraud
5th Place
Michael Sarver
10th Place
Megan Joy
9th Place
Scott MacIntyre
8th Place
Seasons Past
12th place
Vanessa Olivarez = Season 2
Leah LaBelle = Season 3
Lindsey Cardinale = Season 4
Melissa McGhee = Season 5
Brandon Rogers = Season 6
David Hernandez = Season 7
Jasmine Murray & Jorge Nunez = Season 8
11th Place
N/A = Season 1
Charles Grigsby = Season 2
Matt Rogers = Season 3
Mikalah Gordon = Season 4
Kevin Covais = Season 5
Stephanie Edwards = Season 6
Amanda Overmyer = Season 7
Alexis Grace = Season 8
10th Place
N/A = Season 1
Julia DeMato = Season 2
Amy Adams = Season 3
Jessica Sierra = Season 4
Lisa Tucker = Season 5
Chris Sligh = Season 6
Chikezie = Season 7
Michael Sarver = Season 8
9th Place
EJay Day & Jim Verraros = Season 1
Corey Clark (DQed) = Season 2
Camile Velasco = Season 3
Nikko Smith = Season 4
Mandisa = Season 5
Gina Glocksen = Season 6
Ramiele Malubay = Season 7
Megan Joy = Season 8
8th Place
A.J. Gil = Season 1
Rickey Smith = Season 2
Jon Peter Lewis = Season 3
Nadia Turner = Season 4
Bucky Covington = Season 5
Haley Scarnato = Season 6
Michael Johns = Season 7
Scott McIntyre = Season 8
7th Place
Ryan Starr = Season 1
Kimberly Caldwell = Season 2
Jennifer Hudson = Season 3
Anwar Robinson = Season 4
Ace Young = Season 5
Sanjaya Malakar = Season 6
Kristy Lee Cook = Season 7
Lil Rounds = Season 8
6th Place
Christina Christian = Season 1
Carmen Rasmusen = Season 2
John Stevens = Season 3
Constantine Maroulis = Season 4
Kellie Pickler = Season 5
Phil Stacey = Season 6
Carly Smithson = Season 7
Anoop Desai = Season 8
5th Place
RJ Helton = Season 1
Trenyce = Season 2
George Huff = Season 3
Scott Savol = Season 4
Paris Bennett = Season 5
Chris Richardson = Season 6
Brooke White = Season 7
Matt Giraud = Season 8
4th Place
Tamyra Gray = Season 1
Joshua Gracin = Season 2
LaToya London = Season 3
Anthony Fedorov = Season 4
Chris Daughtry = Season 5
LaKisha Jones = Season 6
Jason Castro = Season 7
Allison Iraheta = Season 8
3rd Place
Nikki McKibbin = Season 1
Kimberley Locke = Season 2
Jasmine Trias = Season 3
Vonzell Solomon = Season 4
Elliott Yamin = Season 5
Melinda Doolittle = Season 6
Syesha Mercado = Season 7
Danny Gokey = Season 8
2nd Place
Justin Guarini = Season 1
Clay Aiken = Season 2
Diana DeGarmo = Season 3
Bo Bice = Season 4
Katharine McPhee = Season 5
Blake Lewis = Season 6
David Archuleta = Season 7
Adam Lambert = Season 8
American Idols
Kelly Clarkson = Season 1
Ruben Studdard = Season 2
Fantasia Barrino = Season 3
Carrie Underwood = Season 4
Taylor Hicks = Season 5
Jordin Sparks = Season 6
David Cook = Season 7
Kris Allen = Season 8
Comment Policy
Idol Search
subscription stuff
Blog Stuff
6 Comments:
LOL! It was a Big Fat Zero! They had to know this would happen when they added the fourth judge.
Dori
I love the term "historic" - what a joke - it was as Simon said "unfortunate" - I didn't mind an occational guest judge in the past - but I really dislike the four panel judge idea this season. I am really amazed at their ratings though. Good for them.
connie
The root cause isn't the fourth judge; it's the craptastic direction of the show.
Whoever is directing allows Seacrest to make the show about him and he allows the ridiculous banter between the judges to go on and on and on ad nauseum.
If they would take out all the filler (random sit-down interviews, pre-taped segments about that week's mentor, or--heaven forbid!--a couple of the advertisements, etc.) the show could get good feedback from all the judges and still come in under time.
I think four judges is too many and it gives Simon way too much power (since he breaks all ties). If I were going to scrap a judge, it wouldn't be Paula as most people would assume; I'd get rid of Randy.
Jennifer addressed this last week, but they really need Nigel back!
http://tinyurl.com/idolpictures
Check out all these awesome idol pictures, I love this season and always like to see what I missed in case I don’t get to catch an episode! Enjoy!
the article isn't about 4 judges being bad; it's about the 2 judge commentary each time that's bad.
It's not even about the two-judge commentary. It's about the addition of a fourth judge without any (apparent) thought to the rest of the filler that sends the show into overtime. Something had to give to bring the show in on time, and finally, after all these months, they realized it.
Post a Comment
<< Home